Restaurant · Independent · 122 items on the menu

Mike's New York Pizzeria

Address
CuisineRestaurant
Avg macros987 kcal · 36g protein
Rating4.7(2,000 reviews)
DietaryHas Dairy-free, Has Gluten-free, Has Vegan, Has Vegetarian

The full menu

01

Meat Lovers Pie

Meatball. Pepperonni, Bacon & Sausage with Mozzarella Cheese and homemade red sauce.

3222Cal
130Pro g
289Carb g
172Fat g
02

Sausage Parmigiana Entree

Entrées served with your choice of Pasta Tomato Sauce or Side Garden Salad.

3497Cal
130Pro g
335Carb g
182Fat g
03

Pesto Italiano

Italian Sausage, Roasted Red Peppers, Feta Cheese, Mozzarella, Roasted Garlic with our house made pesto sauce topped with basil + pecorino

3391Cal
126Pro g
324Carb g
177Fat g
04

Meatball Parmigiana Entree

Entrées served with your choice of Pasta Tomato Sauce or Side Garden Salad.

3220Cal
124Pro g
307Carb g
166Fat g
05

The Greek Pizza Pie

Red sauce topped with mozzarella, Feta, kalamata olives, red onions, tomato + spinach

3191Cal
124Pro g
311Carb g
161Fat g
06

Tomato + Pesto Ricotta

Tomato, Ricotta, mozzarella, pesto sauce and fresh garlic topped with pecorino and Basil⁠

3148Cal
122Pro g
302Carb g
161Fat g
07

Pesto Chicken + Basil Pie

Our Fresh Pesto Sauce , Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Pecorino , and Fresh Basil.

3076Cal
120Pro g
298Carb g
156Fat g
08

Spicy Pepperoni Grandma Pizza Pie

Square Pizza w/ Pepperoni, Spicy Sauce, Red Peppers, Mozzarella, Basil , + + SPICY Sauce!

3230Cal
120Pro g
313Carb g
166Fat g
09

Hawaiian

3231Cal
118Pro g
315Carb g
166Fat g
10

Spicy Sausage Grandma Pizza Pie

Square Pizza w/ Spicy Sausage, Red Peppers, Mozzarella, Basil , + + SPICY Sauce!

3100Cal
118Pro g
300Carb g
159Fat g
11

Turkey Meatball Parm Pizza Pie

Homemade Turkey Meatballs, Ricotta Cheese, Mozzarella + Sauce

2970Cal
118Pro g
285Carb g
151Fat g
12

Buffalo Chicken Pie

Spicy Buffalo Chicken generously topped with Mozzarella

3124Cal
116Pro g
302Carb g
161Fat g
13

Chicken Alla Vodka Entree

Chicken, Mushrooms & Diced Onions in a Pink Sauce over penne pasta.

Vegetarian
3150Cal
116Pro g
309Carb g
161Fat g
14

Chicken Alla Vodka Pie

Vodka Sauce, Ricotta Cheese, Sauteed Chicken & Mozzarella

Vegetarian
3035Cal
114Pro g
294Carb g
156Fat g
15

Honey Deniro Grandma Pizza Pie

Square Pizza w/ Fresh Ricotta Cheese, Honey, Mozzarella, Basil , + Crushed Tomatoes

Vegetarian
3023Cal
114Pro g
302Carb g
151Fat g
16

BBQ Chicken Pie

Barbeque Chicken generously topped w/ Mozzarella, red onions, fresh cilantro + topped off with ranch dressing

2928Cal
112Pro g
281Carb g
151Fat g
17

Spinach Artichoke Pie

Spinach, and Artichoke in Cream Sauce with Mozzarella

Vegetarian
3062Cal
112Pro g
302Carb g
156Fat g
18

Tomato + Garlic ( Square Pie)

Square Pizza w/ Mozzarella, Tomatoes , fresh garlic + Basil

Vegetarian
2908Cal
110Pro g
289Carb g
146Fat g
19

Eggplant Parm Pie

Eggplant, Ricotta, Marinara, Mozzarella & Romano Cheese

Vegetarian
2790Cal
108Pro g
268Carb g
143Fat g
20

Eggplant Parmigiana Entree

Entrées served with your choice of Pasta Tomato Sauce or Side Garden Salad.

Vegetarian
2947Cal
108Pro g
289Carb g
151Fat g
21

Grandma Pizza Pie

Square pie w/ mozzarella , crushed tomatoes topped with fresh Basil

Vegetarian
2819Cal
108Pro g
281Carb g
140Fat g
22

Square Pie (Grandma)

Build Your Own (Square) pizza. 8 peices.

Vegetarian
2994Cal
108Pro g
289Carb g
156Fat g
23

Spinach Ricotta Pizza Pie

Spinach, Ricotta, Mozzarella & Romano, No Sauce!

Vegetarian
2724Cal
106Pro g
259Carb g
140Fat g
24

Tomato & Garlic Pie

Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Garlic, Oregano, Grated Cheese, No Sauce!

Vegetarian
2850Cal
104Pro g
281Carb g
146Fat g
25

Half & Half Specialty

Introducing Half + Half. You can now select two different specialty pizzas in one pie!

Vegetarian
2839Cal
102Pro g
274Carb g
148Fat g
26

New York Classic Cheese

Build Your Own Classic New York Cheese Pizza

Vegetarian
2684Cal
96Pro g
259Carb g
140Fat g
27

Gluten Free Crust - Cheese

Build Your Own Gluten-Free(crust) Cheese Pizza. ( The Image illustrates extra toppings added)

VegetarianGluten-free
2472Cal
88Pro g
238Carb g
130Fat g
28

Chicken Alla Vodka

Chicken, Mushrooms & Diced Onions in a Pink Sauce over penne pasta.

629Cal
42Pro g
63Carb g
23Fat g
29

The Butanna Special

Chicken cutlet topped w/ mozzarella cheese and vodka sauce on toasted garlic hero.

672Cal
40Pro g
52Carb g
34Fat g
30

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Chicken Cutlet with Tomato Sauce & Melted Mozzarella on Fresh Garlic Toasted Hero Bread

640Cal
38Pro g
52Carb g
31Fat g
31

Chicken Parmigiana

632Cal
36Pro g
52Carb g
31Fat g
32

Brooklyn Sausage & Peppers Hero

Hot & Sweet Sausage with Tomato Sauce & Melted Mozzarella on Fresh Toasted Garlic Hero Bread

713Cal
35Pro g
50Carb g
42Fat g
33

Sausage & Peppers

709Cal
34Pro g
50Carb g
42Fat g
34

Caesar Salad with Grilled Buffalo Chicken

Romaine Lettuce, Pecorino and Shaved Parmesan Cheese , Garlic Croutons topped with Grilled Buffalo Chicken

384Cal
32Pro g
17Carb g
21Fat g
35

Meatball Parmigiana Hero

Meatballs with Tomato Sauce & Melted Mozzarella on Fresh Garlic Toasted Hero Bread

663Cal
32Pro g
52Carb g
36Fat g
36

Sausage Parmagiana

686Cal
32Pro g
52Carb g
39Fat g
37

Almalfi with Chicken Cutlet

Romaine Lettuce, Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Peppers, Kalamata Olives, Feta Cheese topped with Chicken Cutlet.

368Cal
30Pro g
15Carb g
21Fat g
38

BBQ Chicken Roll

BBQ Chicken rolled with Melted Mozzarella

608Cal
30Pro g
52Carb g
31Fat g
39

Baked Ziti w/ Ricotta

Fresh penne pasta baked with ricotta cheese, red sauce, parmesan, and mozzarella cheese.

577Cal
28Pro g
52Carb g
29Fat g
40

Buffalo Chicken Roll

Our Famous Spicy Buffalo Chicken rolled with Melted Mozzarella

577Cal
28Pro g
52Carb g
29Fat g
41

Garden With Grilled Chicken & Mozzarella

Romaine Lettuce, Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Peppers, Carrots, Mozzarella Cheese topped with Chicken Cutlet.

360Cal
28Pro g
15Carb g
21Fat g
42

Homemade Meat Lasagna

699Cal
28Pro g
65Carb g
36Fat g
43

Meatball Parmigiana

664Cal
28Pro g
56Carb g
36Fat g
44

Stromboli

Ham, salami & Pepperoni rolled with Provolone & Melted Mozzarella Cheese

578Cal
28Pro g
35Carb g
36Fat g
45

Wings

Baked Chicken wings in Buffalo, BBQ, Hot or Lemon Pepper.

387Cal
28Pro g
4Carb g
29Fat g
46

Penne Alla Vodka

Mushrooms & Diced Onions in a Pink Sauce over penne pasta

Vegetarian
738Cal
24Pro g
67Carb g
42Fat g
47

Vegetable Parmigiana

Roasted Broccoli, Spinach, Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions with Tomato Sauce and melted MozzarellaEntrées served with your choice of Pasta Tomato Sauce or Side Garden Salad.

Vegetarian
531Cal
24Pro g
56Carb g
23Fat g
48

2 Pepperoni Slice & 1 Can Of Soda

611Cal
22Pro g
60Carb g
31Fat g
49

Baked Ziti

Vegetarian
634Cal
22Pro g
60Carb g
34Fat g
50

Cheese Calzone

Our Calzones stuffed with a Delectable Mix of Cheeses and Spices

Vegetarian
547Cal
22Pro g
56Carb g
26Fat g
51

Chicken Parmigiana Entree

Entrées served with your choice of Pasta Tomato Sauce or Side Garden Salad.

666Cal
22Pro g
63Carb g
36Fat g
52

The Love Pie

The Love Pie is the way to the heart !

576Cal
22Pro g
52Carb g
31Fat g
53

Baked Ravioli w/ Mozzarella

Fresh baked cheese filled ravioli in our red marinara sauce and baked iwth mozzerella cheese.

Vegetarian
635Cal
20Pro g
63Carb g
34Fat g
54

Cheese Ravioli

Vegetarian
539Cal
20Pro g
56Carb g
26Fat g
55

Pepperoni Honey Deniro

Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Ricotta, Red Sauce,Pecorino, Basil & Honey Drizzle

519Cal
20Pro g
45Carb g
29Fat g
56

Spicy Nana - (Pink Sauce)

Nana's spicy Fra Diavolo Pink Sauce over penne pasta

Vegetarian
594Cal
20Pro g
58Carb g
31Fat g
57

2 Cheese Slices & 1 Can of Soda

571Cal
18Pro g
60Carb g
29Fat g
58

Antipasto Salad

Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Ham, Pepperoni, Salami, Olives & Mozzarella cheese with our Italian House Dressing on the side

451Cal
18Pro g
13Carb g
36Fat g
59

Eggplant Parmigiana

Vegetarian
554Cal
18Pro g
56Carb g
29Fat g
60

Eggplant Parmigiana Roll

Fried Eggplant rolled with Tomato Sauce & Melted Mozzarella

Vegetarian
601Cal
18Pro g
56Carb g
34Fat g
61

Fettuccini Alfredo

Fresh fettuccine tossed with butter and Parmesan cheese

Vegetarian
586Cal
18Pro g
58Carb g
31Fat g
62

Marinara

Choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccini

554Cal
18Pro g
56Carb g
29Fat g
63

Onions & Peppers

Hot & Sweet peppers, onions in red sauce over your choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccini

531Cal
18Pro g
56Carb g
26Fat g
64

Pepperoni Grandma

464Cal
18Pro g
45Carb g
23Fat g
65

Sausage Alla Vodka

Mozzarella, Sausage, Pink Vodka Sauce,, Pecorino, Basil.

Vegetarian
421Cal
18Pro g
35Carb g
23Fat g
66

Spinach Roll

Spinach rolled with Ricotta, Feta & Melted Mozzarella Cheese

Vegetarian
450Cal
18Pro g
30Carb g
29Fat g
67

Broccoli (Garlic & Oil)

Choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccini

Vegetarian
514Cal
16Pro g
54Carb g
26Fat g
68

Penne Alla Vodka- catering

Mushrooms & Diced Onions in a Pink Sauce over penne pasta

Vegetarian
601Cal
16Pro g
58Carb g
34Fat g
69

Pepperoni Alla Vodka

Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Pink Vodka Sauce,,Pecorino, Basil.

Vegetarian
389Cal
16Pro g
35Carb g
21Fat g
70

Spicy Nana- catering (Deep Copy)

Mushrooms & Diced Onions in a Pink Sauce over penne pasta

Vegetarian
601Cal
16Pro g
58Carb g
34Fat g
71

Butter Sauce

Choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccini

Vegetarian
497Cal
14Pro g
52Carb g
26Fat g
72

Garlic & Oil

Choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccini

VegetarianVegan
474Cal
14Pro g
52Carb g
23Fat g
73

Garlic Bread W/ Mozzarella Cheese

Traditional hero toasted with our house-made butter garlic spread. Served with Marinara sauce.

Vegetarian
446Cal
14Pro g
39Carb g
26Fat g
74

Meatballs

Choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Fettuccini

Vegetarian
375Cal
14Pro g
39Carb g
18Fat g
75

Mozzarella Sticks

Homemade Fried mozzarella cheese sticks. Served with Marinara sauce.

Vegetarian
452Cal
14Pro g
35Carb g
29Fat g
76

Spicy Alla Vodka

Mozzarella, Jalapenos, Pink Vodka Sauce,Ricotta, Pecorino, Basil.

Vegetarian
405Cal
14Pro g
35Carb g
23Fat g
77

Tomato Sauce

Choice of pasta: Spaghetti, Penne, Linguine, Fettuccini

Vegetarian
427Cal
14Pro g
52Carb g
18Fat g
78

1 Cheese Slice & 1 Small Garden Salad

Vegetarian
417Cal
12Pro g
45Carb g
21Fat g
79

12 Oz Blue Cheese Dressing

1372Cal
12Pro g
15Carb g
140Fat g
80

Caesar Salad

Romaine Lettuce Tossed w/ Croutons, Caesar Dressing & topped with Parmesan Cheese

Vegetarian
264Cal
12Pro g
13Carb g
18Fat g
81

Fried Ravioli

Fresh fried cheese ravioli. Served with marinara sauce.

Vegetarian
493Cal
12Pro g
41Carb g
31Fat g
82

Garden Salad With Mozzarella

Chopped Romaine lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Red Onions, Carrots topped with shredded Mozzarella Cheese.

Vegetarian
225Cal
12Pro g
15Carb g
13Fat g
83

Gluten Free Cheese

Build Your Own Gluten-Free(crust) Cheese Pizza. ( The Image illustrates extra toppings added)

Gluten-freeVegetarian
297Cal
12Pro g
39Carb g
10Fat g
84

12 Oz Ranch Dressing

1288Cal
10Pro g
19Carb g
130Fat g
85

Amalfi Salad

Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Peppers, Onions, Olives & Feta with our House Dressing on the side

Vegetarian
288Cal
10Pro g
15Carb g
21Fat g
86

Pinwheel

Pepperonni or Vegetables rolled with seasoning and mozzarella cheese

258Cal
10Pro g
19Carb g
16Fat g
87

Anchovies Side

Gluten-free
48Cal
9Pro g
0Carb g
1Fat g
88

Garlic Bread

Traditional hero toasted with our house-made butter garlic spread. Served with Marinara sauce.

Vegetarian
334Cal
8Pro g
35Carb g
18Fat g
89

Pesto Cheese Sticks (8 pieces)

4 Bread Sticks topped with our homemade pesto sauce melted with mozzarella cheese. Served with marinara sauce.

Vegetarian
285Cal
8Pro g
28Carb g
16Fat g
90

Tiramisu

Sponge cake soaked in espresso, topped with mascarpone cream and dusted with cocoa powder

Vegetarian
383Cal
8Pro g
41Carb g
21Fat g
91

Garlic Knots

Fresh baked and tossed in our garlic butter sauce topped with parsley. Served with Marinara sauce.

Vegetarian
298Cal
7Pro g
32Carb g
16Fat g
92

Cannoli

filled with chocolate chip and pistachio

Vegetarian
326Cal
6Pro g
35Carb g
18Fat g
93

Carrot Cake

layers of carrot cake spiced with cinnamon, chopped walnuts and pineapple, covered with a smooth cream cheese topping and sprinkled with crushed walnuts.

Vegetarian
457Cal
6Pro g
50Carb g
26Fat g
94

Garden Salad

Fresh Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Peppers, Onions, Carrots & House Dressing On The Side

VeganVegetarian
125Cal
6Pro g
19Carb g
3Fat g
95

Chocolate Cake

layers of rich fudgy cake and smooth chocolate

Vegetarian
412Cal
5Pro g
45Carb g
23Fat g
96

Red Velvet Cake

A red hued chocolate layer cake, filled and iced wtih a smooth cream cheese frosting, finished with chocolate drizzles and surrounded by red cake crumbs

Vegetarian
450Cal
5Pro g
52Carb g
25Fat g
97

Alfredo Sauce

VegetarianGluten-free
259Cal
4Pro g
2Carb g
26Fat g
98

Anchovies

Gluten-free
16Cal
4Pro g
0Carb g
0Fat g
99

Parmesan Cheese

Gluten-freeVegetarian
67Cal
4Pro g
1Carb g
5Fat g
100

Pink Sauce

202Cal
3Pro g
6Carb g
18Fat g
101

Caesar dressing

Gluten-freeVegetarian
164Cal
2Pro g
1Carb g
17Fat g
102

Pesto Sauce

VeganDairy-freeGluten-free
239Cal
2Pro g
2Carb g
25Fat g
103

1000 Island Dressing

Gluten-freeVegetarian
153Cal
1Pro g
2Carb g
16Fat g
104

Bleu Cheese Dressing

Gluten-free
196Cal
1Pro g
1Carb g
21Fat g
105

Jalapeno Side

VeganDairy-freeGluten-free
39Cal
1Pro g
9Carb g
0Fat g
106

Marinara Sauce

VeganDairy-freeGluten-free
34Cal
1Pro g
8Carb g
0Fat g
107

Ranch Dressing

Gluten-free
141Cal
1Pro g
2Carb g
14Fat g
108

12 Oz Boylan Orange

VeganGluten-freeDairy-free
173Cal
0Pro g
43Carb g
0Fat g
109

12 Oz. Boylan Grape

VeganGluten-freeDairy-free
173Cal
0Pro g
43Carb g
0Fat g
110

12 Oz. Boylan Root Beer

VeganGluten-freeDairy-free
168Cal
0Pro g
42Carb g
0Fat g
111

Balsamic Vinegrette

VeganDairy-freeGluten-free
55Cal
0Pro g
2Carb g
5Fat g
112

BBQ Sauce

VeganDairy-free
65Cal
0Pro g
16Carb g
0Fat g
113

Boylan Shirley Temple 12 Oz.

VeganGluten-freeDairy-free
156Cal
0Pro g
39Carb g
0Fat g
114

Coca-Cola, 16.9oz Bottle

Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love

VeganDairy-free
251Cal
0Pro g
63Carb g
0Fat g
115

Coca-Cola, Can

Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love

VeganDairy-freeGluten-free
168Cal
0Pro g
42Carb g
0Fat g
116

Evian Water

VeganGluten-freeDairy-free
0Cal
0Pro g
0Carb g
0Fat g
117

Fiji Water 16.9 FL Oz

VeganDairy-freeGluten-free
0Cal
0Pro g
0Carb g
0Fat g
118

Honey

VeganDairy-freeGluten-free
73Cal
0Pro g
18Carb g
0Fat g
119

Italian Dressing

VeganDairy-freeGluten-free
121Cal
0Pro g
1Carb g
13Fat g
120

Mexican Coke, Bottle

Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love

VeganGluten-freeDairy-free
168Cal
0Pro g
42Carb g
0Fat g
121

Mild Buffalo Sauce

VeganDairy-freeGluten-free
9Cal
0Pro g
2Carb g
0Fat g
122

Sprite, 12oz Can

Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free

VeganDairy-freeGluten-free
164Cal
0Pro g
41Carb g
0Fat g

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the macros at Mike's New York Pizzeria?
Mike's New York Pizzeria has 122 menu items with full macro data including protein, carbs, fat, and calories for each dish. Browse the full menu above to find items that fit your nutrition targets.
Does Mike's New York Pizzeria have high-protein options?
Yes — use the Fitsy app to filter Mike's New York Pizzeria's menu by your protein target. You can set your daily macro goals and Fitsy will rank every dish by how well it matches.
Is Mike's New York Pizzeria good for macro tracking?
Mike's New York Pizzeria is macro-friendly with detailed nutrition data for its entire menu. Download the Fitsy app to get personalized meal recommendations based on your specific protein, carb, and fat targets.

Find meals at Mike's New York Pizzeria that fit your macros

Set your protein, carb, and fat targets. Fitsy ranks every dish.

Download Fitsy