Restaurant · Independent · 57 items on the menu

Old Gold Tomato Pies

Address
CuisineRestaurant
Avg macros1310 kcal · 53g protein
Rating4.6(57 reviews)
DietaryHas Dairy-free, Has Gluten-free, Has Vegan, Has Vegetarian

The full menu

01

Old Gold Slab Whole Pizza

13"x 18" Whole pie. Cut into 12 slices or party cut (20 slices). Our namesake, tomato, mozzarella, fontina, pecorino, parmesan.

Vegetarian
4488Cal
216Pro g
415Carb g
218Fat g
02

Godson Slab Whole Pizza

13"x 18" Whole pie. Cut into 12 slices or party cut (20 slices). Pepperoni, tomato, mozzarella, and pecorino. Can be made vegetarian or vegan by subbing vegan mozz, parm or Prime Roots Pepperoni.

4252Cal
192Pro g
415Carb g
203Fat g
03

'Nduja and Fig Jam Slab Whole Pie

13"x18" Whole pizza. Cut into 12 slices or party cut (20 slices). Crema, Smokey "Nduja, fig jam, mozzarella and basil.

4589Cal
180Pro g
441Carb g
234Fat g
04

Goon Squad Slab Whole Pizza

13"x 18" Whole pie. Cut into 12 slices or party cut (20 slices). Crab Rangoon Pie, crab, cream cheese, scallion, wontons, chili sauce.

4729Cal
180Pro g
441Carb g
250Fat g
05

Coastal Elite Slab Whole Pizza

13"x 18" Whole Pie. Cut into 12 slices or party cut (20 slices). Creme fraiche, Baja clams, Peads & Barnetts bacon, parsley.

4296Cal
168Pro g
415Carb g
218Fat g
06

Red Flag Slab Whole Pizza

13" x 18" Whole Pie. Cut into 12 slices or party cut (20 slices). Vodka sauce, mozz, pesto cream.

Vegetarian
3875Cal
168Pro g
415Carb g
172Fat g
07

Fun Guy Slab Whole Pizza

13"x 18" Whole pie. Cut into 12 slices or party cut (20 slices). White pie, creme fraiche, market mushrooms, red onion, fennel pollen.

Vegetarian
3804Cal
156Pro g
415Carb g
169Fat g
08

Barney Slab Whole Pizza (V)

13"x 18" Whole Pie. Cut into 12 slices or party cut (20 slices) Vegan Pie with Prime Roots pepperoni, pineapple and pickled jalapenos.

Vegan
3846Cal
144Pro g
467Carb g
156Fat g
09

Vegan Godson Slab Whole Pizza

13"x 18" Whole pie. Cut into 12 slices or party cut (20 slices). Prime Roots Pepperoni, tomato, vegan mozzarella, and vegan parmesan.

Vegan
3846Cal
144Pro g
467Carb g
156Fat g
10

Moral High Ground Slab Whole Pizza (V)

13"x 18" Whole pie. Cut into 12 slices or party cut (20 slices). Vegan pie with artichokes, kalamata olives, spinach and red onion.

Vegan
3310Cal
132Pro g
415Carb g
125Fat g
11

Utica Slab Whole Pizza (V)

13"x 18" Whole slab. Cut into 12 or party cut (20 slices). Vegan mozz, tomato, vegan parm, Sicilian oregano.

Vegan
3414Cal
132Pro g
441Carb g
125Fat g
12

1/2 The Old Gold Pizza

9"x 13" 1/2 slab of The Old Gold. Cut into 6 slices. Our namesake, tomato, mozzarella, fontina, pecorino, parmesan.

Vegetarian
2244Cal
108Pro g
207Carb g
109Fat g
13

1/2 Godson Pizza

9"x 13" 1/2 slab of the Godson. Cut into 6 slices. Pepperoni, tomato, mozzarella, and pecorino. Can be made meat free or vegan by subbing in vegan mozz, parm or Prime Roots Pepperoni.

2126Cal
96Pro g
207Carb g
101Fat g
14

1/2 Coastal Elite Pizza

9"x 13" slab of The Coastal Elite. Cut into 6 slices. Creme fraiche, Baja clams, Peads & Barnetts bacon, parsley.

2102Cal
90Pro g
207Carb g
101Fat g
15

1/2 Goon Squad Pizza

9"x13" 1/2 Slab of The Goon Squad. Cut into 6 slices. Crab Rangoon on pizza. Cream cheese, lump crab, scallions, fried wontons, sweet chili sauce.

2008Cal
84Pro g
207Carb g
94Fat g
16

1/2 Red Flag Pizza

9" x 13" 1/2 slab of the Red Flag Pizza. Cut into 6 slices. Vodka sauce, mozz, pesto cream.

Vegetarian
2008Cal
84Pro g
207Carb g
94Fat g
17

1/2 Fun Guy Pizza

9"x 13" 1/2 slab of our Fun Guy Pie. Cut into 6 slices. White pie, creme fraiche, market mushrooms, red onion, fennel pollen.

Vegetarian
1902Cal
78Pro g
207Carb g
85Fat g
18

1/2 Barney Pizza

9"x 13" 1/2 slab of the Barney. Cut into 6 slices. Vegan Pie with Prime Roots pepperoni, pineapple and pickled jalapenos.

Vegan
1923Cal
72Pro g
233Carb g
78Fat g
19

1/2 Vegan Godson

9"x 13" 1/2 slab of the Vegan Godson. Cut into 6 slices. Prime Roots Pepperoni, tomato, vegan mozzarella, and vegan parmesan.

Vegan
1923Cal
72Pro g
233Carb g
78Fat g
20

1/2 "Nduja and Fig Jam Pizza

9"x13" 1/2 Slab of the 'Nduja and Fig Jam Pizza. Cut into 6 slices. Crema, 'Nduja, fig jam, mozzarella and basil.

1795Cal
66Pro g
207Carb g
78Fat g
21

1/2 Moral High Ground Pizza

9"x 13" 1/2 slab of the Moral High Ground. Cut into 6 slices. Vegan pie with artichokes, kalamata olives, spinach and red onion.

Vegan
1655Cal
66Pro g
207Carb g
62Fat g
22

1/2 Pizza Utica Tomato Pie

9"x13" 1/2 slab of our Utica Tomato Pie. Cut into 6 slices. Vegan mozz, tomato, vegan parm, Sicilian oregano.

Vegan
1707Cal
66Pro g
220Carb g
62Fat g
23

Whole Pie Ricotta

1 quart of our house seasoned ricotta for a whole pie.

VegetarianGluten-free
585Cal
28Pro g
13Carb g
47Fat g
24

Gabagool Sandwich

Capocollo sandwich on our house focaccia bread with pesto mayonnaise, sliced provolone, pickled banana peppers and shredded lettuce.

571Cal
22Pro g
39Carb g
36Fat g
25

1/2 Pie Ricotta

Add Ricotta to any 1/2 size pie.

VegetarianGluten-free
391Cal
19Pro g
9Carb g
31Fat g
26

Add Ricotta

Add a generous dollop of our seasoned ricotta to any slice.

Vegetarian
174Cal
18Pro g
2Carb g
10Fat g
27

Coastal Elite Slice

Creme fraiche, Baja clams, Peads & Barnetts bacon, parsley.

374Cal
18Pro g
35Carb g
18Fat g
28

Old Gold Slice

Slice of our namesake, tomato, mozzarella, fontina, pecorino, parmesan.

Vegetarian
374Cal
18Pro g
35Carb g
18Fat g
29

Sausage Pepper and onion

Slice of our sicilian with sausage, spicy Mama Lil's peppers and baby broccoli

379Cal
17Pro g
37Carb g
18Fat g
30

Godson Slice

Slice of pepperoni, tomato, mozzarella and pecorino. Can be made vegetarian or vegan by subbing vegan mozz, parm or Prime Roots Pepperoni.

354Cal
16Pro g
35Carb g
17Fat g
31

Goon Squad Slice

Crab Rangoon slice, lump crab, cream cheese, scallion, wonton, chili sauce

398Cal
16Pro g
37Carb g
21Fat g
32

Vegan Sandwich

Vegan version of our Gabagool Sandwich.

Vegan
413Cal
16Pro g
35Carb g
23Fat g
33

'Nduja and Fig Jam Slice

Slice with smokey 'nduja sausage, fig jam, basil, cream and mozz.

417Cal
15Pro g
37Carb g
23Fat g
34

Red Flag Slice

A slice of the bad decision you can't help but make. Vodka sauce, mozz, and pesto cream. Instant classic.

Vegetarian
381Cal
14Pro g
35Carb g
21Fat g
35

Fun Guy Slice

Slice of white pie, creme fraiche, market mushrooms, red onion, fennel pollen.

Vegetarian
342Cal
13Pro g
35Carb g
17Fat g
36

Barney Slice (V)

Vegan Slice with Prime Roots pepperoni, pineapple and pickled jalapenos

Vegan
321Cal
12Pro g
39Carb g
13Fat g
37

Vegan Godson Slice

Our bestselling pepperoni slice now made plant-based. Prime Roots Pepperoni, vegan mozzarella, vegan parmesan.

Vegan
321Cal
12Pro g
39Carb g
13Fat g
38

Moral High Ground Slice (V)

Slice of vegan pie with artichokes, kalamata olives, spinach and red onion.

Vegan
276Cal
11Pro g
35Carb g
10Fat g
39

Utica Slice (V)

Slice of Utica Tomato Pie. Vegan mozz, tomato, vegan parm, Sicilian oregano.

Vegan
284Cal
11Pro g
37Carb g
10Fat g
40

Saigon Caesar (V)

Market Lettuce, makrut lime, tofu dressing, herbs, focaccia crumbles, parm.

Vegan
209Cal
10Pro g
13Carb g
13Fat g
41

Add Caesar Salad (V)

Add a serving of our Saigon caesar to any slice.

Vegetarian
137Cal
8Pro g
9Carb g
8Fat g
42

Salad Days (V)

Little Gem Lettuce, avocado dressing, sugar-snap peas, strawberries, radish, candied pecans.

Vegan
250Cal
8Pro g
19Carb g
16Fat g
43

Focaccia (V)

House Focaccia Bread with Castelvetrano olives, rosemary and sea salt.

Vegan
163Cal
6Pro g
17Carb g
8Fat g
44

Add Anchovy

Add some salty little fishys to any slice.

26Cal
5Pro g
0Carb g
1Fat g
45

Baker's Bench Choco Chip Cookie (V)

Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie from our dear friends at Baker's Bench.

VeganVegetarianDairy-free
331Cal
3Pro g
39Carb g
18Fat g
46

Side Tofu Ranch (V)

2 oz. side of our housemade tofu ranch.

VeganVegetarianDairy-free
103Cal
3Pro g
2Carb g
9Fat g
47

Balo Cherry Fig Leaf Kombucha

12 oz. can of locally made Cherry Fig Leaf Raw Kombucha.

47Cal
1Pro g
11Carb g
0Fat g
48

Balo Strawberry Fennel Flower Kombucha

12 oz. can of locally made Strawberry Fennel Flower Raw Kombucha.

47Cal
1Pro g
11Carb g
0Fat g
49

YuzuCo Green Tea Yuzu-ade

12 oz. can of YuzuCo Green Tea Yuzu-ade.

56Cal
1Pro g
13Carb g
0Fat g
50

YuzuCo Yuzu-ade

12 oz. can of YuzuCo Yuzu-ade.

56Cal
1Pro g
13Carb g
0Fat g
51

1/2 Pie Honey

Add our Farmer's Market Honey to any 1/2 pie.

VeganVegetarianDairy-free
181Cal
0Pro g
45Carb g
0Fat g
52

Add Honey

Add some Lily's Eggs sage honey from the Farmer's Market to any slice.

VeganVegetarianDairy-free
69Cal
0Pro g
17Carb g
0Fat g
53

Coca-Cola

12 oz. can of Coke.

168Cal
0Pro g
42Carb g
0Fat g
54

Dr. Brown's Cream Soda

12 oz. can of Dr. Brown's Cream Soda.

207Cal
0Pro g
52Carb g
0Fat g
55

Dr. Browns Black Cherry Soda

12 oz. can of Dr. Brown's Black Cherry Soda.

151Cal
0Pro g
38Carb g
0Fat g
56

Sparkling Agua de Piedra

22 oz. bottle of sparkling spring water.

0Cal
0Pro g
0Carb g
0Fat g
57

Whole Pie Honey

Side of Lily's Eggs honey from the Farmer's Market for a whole pie.

VeganVegetarianDairy-free
276Cal
0Pro g
69Carb g
0Fat g

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the macros at Old Gold Tomato Pies?
Old Gold Tomato Pies has 57 menu items with full macro data including protein, carbs, fat, and calories for each dish. Browse the full menu above to find items that fit your nutrition targets.
Does Old Gold Tomato Pies have high-protein options?
Yes — use the Fitsy app to filter Old Gold Tomato Pies's menu by your protein target. You can set your daily macro goals and Fitsy will rank every dish by how well it matches.
Is Old Gold Tomato Pies good for macro tracking?
Old Gold Tomato Pies is macro-friendly with detailed nutrition data for its entire menu. Download the Fitsy app to get personalized meal recommendations based on your specific protein, carb, and fat targets.

Find meals at Old Gold Tomato Pies that fit your macros

Set your protein, carb, and fat targets. Fitsy ranks every dish.

Download Fitsy